Posts

What You Expect Matters

Yesterday's post might seem like so many arguments about angels on pinheads. Here's where the rubber meets the road: if you struggle with sin related to (for example) anger, envy, same sex attraction, opposite sex attraction, or substance abuse, what you believe about how God works matters. If you are in a church in the Holiness Movement, chances are that you have heard something to this effect: When you get saved, the "tree" of sin in your heart is chopped down, so it stops bearing fruit (acts of sin), but the "stump" is still there. If the stump is allowed to remain, new shoots of sin will pop up from it occasionally. To walk steadily with God, not falling into sin periodically, God will have to remove the stump by entirely sanctifying you. What you expect to happen when you are entirely sanctified matters. When we use language for inherited depravity like "stump" or "heart of stone," I think there's a danger that people ...

Hearts of Stone

As I've studied Galatians recently, it has stuck out to me that for all Paul's talking about walking in the Spirit, he doesn't say anything about something that needs to be removed inside a person for them to walk in the Spirit. The classic American Holiness way of talking about inherited depravity is to describe it as something that needs to be removed, a blight on the landscape of the heart. It's interesting to me that Paul doesn't reference anything needing to be removed in Galatians. I understand this is an argument from silence, but I think it's worth noticing. If inherited depravity is something that needs to be removed from the heart, I would have expected Paul to say something about that. But he doesn't. He says that if you walk in the Spirit, you will not fulfill the desires of the flesh (Gal. 5:16). Someone asked me recently, "What about Ezekiel's description of God replacing a heart of stone with a heart of flesh?" That happens...

Is the Spirit Actually Enough?

Image
Paul actually thinks that walking in step with the Spirit is sufficient for Christians to know how to live (Gal. 5:16-25). If someone's not willing to walk in step with the Spirit, no guidelines of any kind will help (Gal. 5:2-4). Do I actually think that? Do you actually think that?

Differences in Strokes and Folks

Image
At IHC this year, I heard a young boy's high, clear voice singing, "The old ledger is clear!" I don't know if I've ever seen an actual ledger. I guess a spreadsheet would be the modern equivalent. I wondered if he knew what an old ledger was. There were people listening to him sing who were blessed by the song. I can figure out what the image means--ledgers are where debts are recorded, and one way you can think about sins is as unpayable debts against God, so for your ledger to be clear means your unpayable debts have been paid by Jesus' death. But the image of a ledger doesn't connect with me. It doesn't bless me. That doesn't mean there's something wrong with the image. If I had grown up in a time when actual physical ledgers were used for the recording of debts, that image would probably connect with me. Maybe that has something to do with why it blessed some people at IHC. For someone who grew up going to camp meetings, camp mee...

Not Everyone Cares

I've been reading Seth Godin's blog and book ( Unleashing the Ideavirus ) at the same time as Dallas Willard's The Allure of Gentleness . It's a good combination of ideas. Both have spent lifetimes learning and teaching about how people work. Godin says , "Organizations that grow start by selling their services and products to people who care." That statement is relevant to evangelism and apologetics, I think. The majority of people do not care enough about living life well to seek out mentors. (Jesus is the ultimate mentor.) Maybe they believe that they are actually amazing at living life all on their own, but I think they are more likely complacent. Life on their own doesn't hurt enough yet for them to care about seeking something more. Jesus' call comes to people who care enough to want something different. Are you weary? You don't have to be (Matt. 11:28-30). But do you care enough to want a solution (John 5:6)? Godin's marketing ...

Higher Education is Dangerous

Image
The pastor told me, "Some of the people I trust most have discouraged me from taking graduate classes. They say, 'What's the point of education? Aren't you supposed to depend on the Holy Spirit for help with preaching the Word?'" They're not wrong--education can be dangerous. Pride is one of the primary dangers in the pursuit of knowledge. Paul wrote to the Corinthians that knowledge puffs up, while love builds up (1 Cor. 8:1). "Puffing up" yields a deceptive appearance of growth, while "building up" is authentic growth. The Corinthians were taking pride in their knowledge that idols are just powerless material, and while Paul agrees (1 Cor. 8:4-6), he also puts their strutting knowledge in perspective (1 Cor. 8:2): they don't know anything yet like they ought to, because they are using their knowledge to sin against others (1 Cor. 8:7, 12). If education did always leads to pride, then we would have to avoid education. But I d...